One of the pleasant problems of working in the publishing
industry is that it is not uncommon to be faced with a saturation of quality
literature when a new trend arises. I have found this to be particularly
so for YA – in recent years, I’ve been fortunate enough to read some absolutely
top-notch paranormal fiction, dystopian fiction, and now, the ubiquitous
“real-lit”. The problem that I find in this is that once I’ve read three
of four books in a rising genre, I have a tendency to become bored and even
jaded. This is natural; after all, a trend is necessarily impermanent,
and the great strength of literature lies in its diversity. However, it
does leave me worried that some superbly talented authors may miss out on the
recognition and success that they deserve, simply because their work appears
too late into a trend that is already waning.
Months ago, when I first read the manuscript for I Was
Here, I was absolutely stunned. In the time between then and now, I
read a number of other real-lit YA books, including The Perks of Being a
Wallflower, Noggin, Will Grayson Will Grayson, and of course,
The Fault in Our Stars. Now that I’m preparing, finally, to sell I
Was Here into February 2015, I found myself fretting that perhaps the book
was overstated in my remembered estimation; maybe it was merely the first
outstanding book I’d read in a genre that has become incredibly popular and
introduced some phenomenal books to the reading public. Quite apart from
this, I was also concerned that I’d forgotten bits and pieces of the book – I
remember the main plot, and I remember how it made me feel, but I couldn’t
recall the names of the characters, and I worried that I may have inadvertently
mixed up parts of the story with other real-lit books (another hazard of
literary trends). So yesterday afternoon, while the rain drummed quietly
outside, I sat down on the couch to re-read it.
In a bizarre simultaneity, the experience of reading the
book felt both familiar and new. Before I was two chapters in, I
remembered why I adored the main character, why I felt pain when she did, why I
begged her to hold on and rejoiced when she did. And yet, the experience
was also fresh, even in a reading climate soaked with real-lit – with good
real-lit.
The story follows Cody, a teenage girl a couple of years out
of high school. Her best friend, Meg, had moved away for college the
previous year, the friendship had cooled, and then, shockingly and seemingly
out of the blue, Meg committed suicide. Cody is devastated, bewildered,
and furious both with Meg and herself – how could she be Meg’s best friend and
not know that something was wrong? Cody offers to help Meg’s distraught
parents by travelling to Meg’s college share-house and collecting her belongings,
but what she discovers there leads her to believe that Meg may have been talked
or coerced into suicide. She embarks on an investigation, bordering on
obsessive vendetta, that turns into something utterly unexpected both for Cody
and for the reader.
From the first sentence, Gayle Forman’s incredible writing
talent is undeniable. Every character in the book is so real, so
perfectly imperfect, that I am half-convinced that the events in the book must
somewhere have actually happened. The dialogue, the settings, the
language, are all faultless. The plot moves both subtly and deceptively,
twisting sharply at times, but softly enough to draw the compelled reader
along.
The force of this book hit me like a juggernaut. It is
beautiful, heartbreaking, uplifting, enduring, and for me, profoundly
close. As someone who suffers from mental illness, and has a beloved friend affected by depression, I am in the unusual position of being
able to strongly identify with both Meg and Cody – evoking remembered feelings
of both desperation and terror. It cut to the core, and yet even as I was
shedding tears at the end of the book (for the second time), it made me feel
hopeful – supremely, warmly, hopeful. Yes, Meg took her own life, which
is utterly and unmistakably tragic, but in the climactic scene when Cody
chooses life, hope resonates and illuminates fiercely.
I don’t believe this book is only for readers who know
depression. This book is for anyone who has ever loved, who has ever been
worried about a friend, who has ever had even a single moment without
hope. This book should be read by everyone – it will convince you that
even in the darkest night, hope is an enduring flame that never needs to be –
and never should be – extinguished. This book is immense.
There are many parents who worry about their teens reading
books dealing with depression and suicide, and I believe this concern is
completely reasonable. But the first thing I did after finishing I Was
Here was to call my best friend. We made a pact right there – no
matter how great the darkness, no matter how deep the chasm, and no matter if
it seems like the end is inevitable, we will always, always, call for
help.
~
This book will be available from February 1st, 2015 - please support the Australian book industry and buy at your local bookstore, or if you would like to buy online, please consider an Australian online store such as Booktopia or Dymocks.
with love from the lit dancer
artemis